NewsCrime and Courts

Actions

Montana wrongful rape conviction claim fails in court

Jury rejects Cody Marble’s claim to a $750,000 judgment
marble.png
Posted at 3:16 PM, May 23, 2024

MISSOULA — In the first and last test of a Montana law providing compensation to those wrongly convicted of a crime, a Missoula jury on Tuesday, May 21, 2024, rejected an attempt by Cody Marble to claim a $750,000 judgment — despite his exoneration seven years ago on a rape conviction.

The state district court jury, after five-plus hours of deliberation following a seven-day trial, said Marble did not prove his innocence in the 22-year-old rape case, and therefore isn’t entitled to the money, reports the Montana Free Press.

Marble was convicted in late 2002 of raping a fellow inmate in the Missoula County Juvenile Detention Center earlier that year.

Yet Marble, now 39, has always asserted his innocence, saying the crime never occurred. After a years-long court battle, he was exonerated of the charge in 2017 after the Montana Supreme Court said prosecutors should re-examine evidence in the case.

At the time, Missoula County Attorney Kirsten Pabst said her review of the case convinced her Marble was falsely convicted and that he could not be convicted if retried. She filed to dismiss the charge in 2016 and a judge agreed a year later, allowing Marble to be freed from prison.

But when Marble filed a claim in 2021 under a new state law to be compensated for his wrongful conviction, Missoula County and the state aggressively fought his claim, arguing that the exoneration did not mean he was innocent.

The law — which is no longer on the books — required claimants to prove their innocence to receive compensation.

During closing arguments Tuesday, Andrew Huppert, an attorney representing Missoula County, said the case for Marble’s innocence was built on a “house of lies” by Marble and the Montana Innocence Project, which assisted with Marble’s attempt to overturn his conviction.

Huppert ridiculed Marble’s assertion that the alleged victim — Robert Thomas, age 13 in 2002 — and several other detention center inmates had conspired to concoct the story that Marble raped Thomas in March 2002.

Thomas and the other inmates testified against Marble at his 2002 trial, saying Marble raped Thomas in the shower of the prison cell “pod” where they were housed.

“I just never figured out the logic of that conspiracy,” Huppert said sarcastically.

Marble’s lead attorney, Mark Kovacich of Great Falls, asked the jury Tuesday who was more likely to lie: A group of troubled kids in juvenile lockup, or the lineup of adult professionals, including detention center guards on staff when the alleged incident occurred and Innocence Project officials, who said during trial they’re convinced the crime never occurred.

Kovacich also said the county and state never answered a central question: Why would Marble commit such a crime, in full view of other inmates, when guards could possibly see or hear it, two days before he was to be released from the detention center?

“Why would he commit a brutal rape in that tiny pod?” Kovacich said.

Marble-Cody LJC.jpg
Undated file photo of Cody Marble

Marble took the witness stand last week during the trial, asserting his innocence and saying he never went into the shower with Thomas in 2002 and did not assault or rape him in any way.

He also blasted the county and its attorneys for now claiming he is guilty, after the county had said eight years ago that the conviction was flawed and the charge should be dismissed.

“They want to make sure that they get all the money, profit off my misery, and I get nothing,” Marble said, motioning at the county’s attorneys. “That law firm, right there.”

Missoula County told Montana Free Press it had paid the private law firm representing the county in the Marble case about $280,000 in fees and costs through the end of March. That amount does not include any trial costs and charges.

Thomas — the alleged victim in the 2002 rape — fatally shot himself 10 years ago after an hours-long standoff with police in Havre. He had been on parole from prison after a rape conviction, but hadn’t reported to his parole officer for months, and fled when police stopped him, leading to the standoff.

At the behest of the Innocence Project, Thomas wrote a statement in 2010 saying that Marble never raped him and that he had lied as part of a plot to harm Marble.

But after being told later by then-Missoula County Attorney Fred Van Valkenburg that he could be charged with perjury, Thomas recanted his admission and testified under oath at a 2012 hearing that Marble did rape him in 2002.

Marble is the only person to file a claim under Montana’s 2021 law designed to compensate the wrongfully convicted — and the last. The law expired last year after Gov. Greg Gianforte vetoed a bill that would have extended it past June 2023.

A Gianforte veto in 2021 also altered the nature of the proposed initial law, making the county where the person had been prosecuted responsible for 75% of the costs of any award. Before that change, the state had been responsible for the entire award.

The change brought Missoula County and its staunch opposition into Marble’s case.